Skip to contentSister site·In Hot Springs, Arkansas? bnbhot.com has these same free tools for Hot Springs real estate and short-term rentals. Visit bnbhot.com →

BNB ATX › Taxes › Rent vs buy

Rent vs buy

Rent or buy in Austin? Put your own numbers in.

This calculator compares the full cost of owning against the full cost of renting over the years you plan to stay. It shows its work, and it lets you add short-term-rental income if you have a real basis for it.

Buying

Renting

Time

$0

    Estimate only. Preloaded values are placeholders so the tool runs. They are not Austin averages, forecasts or quotes. Replace the price, the rent, the rate and the tax percentage with your own.

    How the math works

    • Net cost of buying is every dollar paid out as an owner (down payment, closing costs, mortgage payments, property tax, insurance, upkeep, HOA, minus any rental income you enter) less the equity you walk away with after selling costs and the loan payoff.
    • Net cost of renting is total rent paid, less the growth a renter earns by investing the cash a buyer would have put into the down payment and closing costs.
    • Property tax and upkeep track the home’s value each year. Insurance and HOA stay flat.
    • Left out on purpose: federal tax deductions, mortgage insurance, monthly savings differences between the two paths, renter’s insurance and moving costs. Each can matter. None is hidden inside a number above.

    Picking Texas-realistic inputs

    • Property tax. Inside Austin, 2026 rates total about 2.1211% before exemptions, as reported. A homestead’s effective rate is lower, around 1.6% to 1.7% on a mid-priced home by our estimate. Get your own figure from the estimator and type it in.
    • Insurance. Texas premiums are high and vary a lot by roof age and hail history. Use a real quote.
    • Selling costs. Commission, the owner’s title policy and concessions. Build yours on the closing-cost estimator.
    • Appreciation. Austin prices have run up hard and have also fallen. Try a low case, zero, and a negative year or two before you believe a happy answer.
    • Rent. Use the asking rent on a home you would actually choose instead, not a citywide figure.

    About the STR income line

    Leave it at zero unless three things are true. The address can be licensed under Austin’s rules. You will hold that license yourself, since a seller’s license does not transfer. And the figure you enter is net: after platform fees, cleaning, supplies, extra utilities, the license fee and your own vacancy guess. Hotel occupancy tax is collected from guests on top of the rate, so it should not be in your income number at all.

    If you plan to live in the home and host part of it, that is the owner-occupied license type. Start with the eligibility checker, and sketch gross revenue with the revenue estimator before netting it down.

    A purchase that only works with rental income is a business plan with a mortgage attached. Run the calculator at zero first.

    Questions

    Is it better to rent or buy in Austin right now?

    There is no single answer. It turns on how long you will stay, the rent on a comparable home, your mortgage rate and what prices do. Short stays favor renting because buying and selling costs are large. Run your own numbers.

    Why is property tax such a big line in this calculator?

    Texas has no state income tax and funds local government largely through property tax. Inside Austin the 2026 rates total roughly 2.1% of taxable value before exemptions, so tax can rival insurance and upkeep combined.

    Can I count short-term-rental income when I buy?

    Only if the address can be licensed and you hold the license. Austin requires a city license for stays under 30 days, and a license does not transfer from the seller. Treat the income as upside, not as a given.

    This is general information, dated 2026-11-10. It is not tax, legal or lending advice. Rates and exemptions change every year, so check TCAD and your own tax bill before you act on a number.

    Sources (checked 2026-11-10):

    2026 unit rates on this site are the adopted rates as reported in October 2026 local coverage. Your tax bill and the Travis County Tax Office are the final word.